Home Blog Page 905

Dr Taufe'ulungaki: my being a non-elected member has been a very sore issue

“BEING the only woman in Parliament is not unique to me,” says the Hon. Minister of Education Dr. ‘Ana Taufe’ulungaki when speaking to 30 members of the first ever Practice Parliament for Women in Tonga.

Sharing her experience as the only female MP in Parliament, Dr. Taufe’ulungaki says there were others before her including her Royal Highness Princess Siu’ilikutapu and Papiloa Foliaki and others. However the difference is that they were elected and she was not.

“It would not have mattered too much if it were the political structure but in the new political system, where Tonga is moving towards greater representation of the people, my being a non-elected member has been a very sore issue for many of my fellow MPs,” says Dr. ‘Ana Taufe’ulungaki.

She adds MPs object to her presence in the House, not so much because she was a woman, but to the fact that in their perceptions, she came through the back door.

“From their view points, the elected members had sacrificed their time, money, careers, and family life, in pursuit of their political goals. The campaign trail was a long and difficult one for many. Through such pains, they have earned their right to be People’s Representatives, and the right to speak on behalf of their constituencies,” say Dr. Taufe’ulungaki.

She further explains that she understands how the other MPs feel about her and encouraged them never to give up.

"If you wish participate fully in the processes of developing, scrutinizing, submitting, and approving good laws for the development of this country. I can assure you will be welcomed not as a woman, but as a fully deserving member of Parliament. You will have earned the right to be there,” emphasized Dr. Taufe’ulungaki.

She says women are already well equipped to cope with the duties and responsibilities of a parliamentarian. Therefore they do not need to justify themselves to the nation and especially to the men of Tonga that they are capable.

She says she gets upset when people say that women need to practice how to be a parliamentarian, as if a woman by virtue of her biological nature needs special qualifications, other than already specified by law.

“Clause 65 of the Constitution allows anyone who is 21 or more, not a noble, is not insane or has been convicted of a criminal offence punishable by imprisonment for more than two years – to vote in an election or to run for Parliament,” says the non elected MP.

Challenges encountered

Dr. Taufe’ulungaki also shared other challenges she encountered being the only female MP in Parliament.

That includes dealing with the boredom of sitting for long periods and stressing out thinking about the outstanding matters waiting for her in the office that must be dealt with expeditiously.

Another challenge is trying to balance the work of the Ministry and that of Parliament, making adequate time for both and try to do both effectively and efficiently.

Another obstacle she outlines was having enough time to read and absorb the various pieces of legislation that will be debated in the House is another obstacles the Hon. Minister had also encountered. And making attempts to see how each piece is linked to existing legislations and to the Constitution.

She also mentions that coping with the social demands of being a minister an issue.

“Social events demand a great deal from one’s time but these come with the territory. I find this aspect of my life and work quite draining on my energy and personal resources.

Budgeting time for professional and personal development was another problem. Therefore Dr. Taufe’ulungaki advises participants that keeping oneself informed and aware of issues in the country, the region and globally.

“One needs to have access to quality research and support.

She also reveals the importance of support group and quality advice from diverse stakeholders, including donors and development partners. Dr. Taufe’ulungaki mentions that during the Vote of No Confidence period, the support of the Fakatouhama Group was immensely reassuring.

Therefore she stresses that such support groups is needed not just in time of crises but at all times.

The academic scholar also points out the importance of ensuring that one is thoroughly grounded in Tonga’s contexts.

"One’s work is meaningless unless it is thoroughly grounded in the contexts of Tonga. We have to understand our people, our land, our history, culture and heritage, our language, our beliefs and values, who we are, where we come from, and where we would like to be. Unless we have such understandings, our work will be rootless and worthless,” the Hon. Education Minister explains.

Dr. Taufe’ulungaki concludes sharing her experiences with the 30 member of the Practice Parliament by stressing the importance of behaving ethically at all times and an unwavering faith in God’s grace, mercy, love and manifold blessings.

“Ethics is essential to our work and the purposes for which we work. Unless we are ethical beings in every way, we cannot make the difference that we purport to work towards. Transparency, accountability, honest, integrity, truthfulness, are important but so are the values that underpin all our relationship – ‘ofa faka’apa’apa, lototo, mamahi’i me’a, feveitokai’aki and tauhi vaha’a. With such values we cannot go wrong,” says the Hon. Education Minister.

SOURCE: parliament.gov.to

Dr Malakai 'Ake laid to rest

Nuku’alofa – Health and medical professional, Dr Malakai ‘Ake, 63, was laid to rest Tuesday 8 in Kolomotu’a.  

He served the government of Tonga’s ministry of health for more than 30 years in which he became the Ministry's Chief Medical Officer before it was revealed he had cancer.

Born on 28 May 1951, ‘Ake was the fourth in seven siblings.

His parents Taniela and Matelita ‘Ake of Kolomotu’a resided in Fiji.

‘Ake was adopted by his paternal aunt, ‘Aulola who married his adoptive father Vili Molofaha of Talau, Neiafu, Vava’u.

They named him as Sione Pusiaki a name 'Ake was widely known with to most Tongans.

He went to Tonga High School and also educated overseas including Singapore where he was awarded with his Masters.

Ake is specially remembered as a person who welcome anyone who sought his medical assistance anytime whether in hospital, his residence or even in public places.

“He was a man of honour,” a tribute read during his funeral service says.

 Yesterday his funeral service at Saione Church was led by FWC President Dr ‘Ahio, attended by His Royal Highness Prince Tupouto’a and members of the Royal Family.

The Prime Minister Lord Tu’ivakano also attended with senior members from government.

‘Ake is survived by his wife Nanuma Finau of Houma, Tongatapu with their seven children.  

Featured image by Paula Moimoi Latu

Tonga agricultural show 6-23 August 2014

His Majesty’s Cabinet has approved on the 28th March, 2014 the official dates for the 2014 Royal Agricultural Show.

This year, in addition to the Royal Agricultural Show, Fisheries and Industrial Show, there will also be a special event for Sports and Market Day. The dates for the 2014 Royal Agricultural, Fisheries and Industrial Show are as follows:

Time

Place

Wednesday, 6th August 2014

Hold Agricultural Show in NIUATOPUTAPU

Thursday, 7th August 2014

Hold Agricultural Show in NIUAFO’OU

Saturday, 9th August 2014

Hold Agricultural Show in VAVA’U

Friday, 15th August 2014

Hold Agricultural Show in ‘EUA

Friday 22nd August 2014

Hold Agricultural Show in TONGATAPU

Saturday 23rd August 2014

Sports and Market Day for TONGATAPU SHOW


The Ha’apai Group will not be able to hold an Agricultural Show this year, due to the damages caused to the islands by Tropical Cyclone Ian in January.

Although Ha’apai will not hold the event in 2014, the normal prejudged competitions will be carried out for competitors and will make allowance to cover the costs for transport of their exhibits and prize-winners to be awarded during the Show in Tongatapu. According to the Ministry of Agriculture, the prejudged competitions in Ha’apai will complement the efforts achieved during the post cyclone disaster response development.

This annual event is coordinated by the Ministry of Agriculture, Food, Forests and Fisheries to encourage the developments of the agricultural, livestock and fisheries sector and continue to ensure that food security is sustained for the people of Tonga throughout the Kingdom.

Fofo’anga marks Koloamatangi’s associate professorship

The Auckland-based Fofo’anga kava club specially marked its 36th birthday last month by celebrating the appointment of one of its most devoted members, Malakai Koloamatangi, as associate professor at the University of Massey. Dr Koloamatangi was blessed during a prayer service organised by the members of the club at the Richmond Tongan United Church chapel.

General Secretary of the club, Viliami Teki Mausa Lavulo, said the program for the day was run by members of the club including the prayer service.

“We have our own faifekaus (ministers) and senior members of the club including Sele Latu, Lutui Palelei (Dr Taniela Lutui), Nalesoni Tupou, Tomasi Taukei’aho who given tasks to play during the service ranging from bible reading to hymns and to speech.

Koloamatangi was called to the front during the service and he was blessed by Rev 'Ilomaisini Lea who also said a prayer for him," Lavulo added

The malanga (sermon) of the day was led by Rev Francis Holani, Former President of Tongan United Church in Auckland, the secretary said.

Rev Setelo Katoa and Rev ‘Ilomaisini Lea were also assisted Rev Holani in leading the prayer service. 

Ikalahi, a representative from Sydney Fofo’anga, attended the ceremony and he was given the role of reading one of the hymns.

Lavulo announced the club’s 2014 annual plan during the ceremony and a word of thanks was presented by Mohetaulanga Kupu, one of the founding members of the Fofo’anga Club in Auckland in 1978.

Kalolaine Lavulo performed a tau’olunga (solo dance) as the only entertainment of the day accompanied Dr Koloamatangi and the Fofo’anga band.

"Koloamatangi’s thesis was entitled Constitutionalism, Culture and Democracy: Tongan Politics Between 1991 and 1996.

"His research interests include democratisation, democratic theory and practice, international political economy, Pacific politics and economic development and the universality of ideas".

Not only is Koloamatangi highly educated but his musical talent as a lead vocalist and guitarist has proved  exceptional in the club’s mission to unite members, a role performed  by his late father Saimone Koloamatangi.

Konitone

The late Koloamatangi, a key member of the Fofo’anga club in Tonga, established the New Zealand-based Fofo’anga in 1978. 

The club embraces friendships and brotherhood under the one konitone policy (word coined by members from konisitutone) to refer to constitution – “Lau pe  ua ko e taha – Regard two as one, “ko ho’o me’a ko ‘etau me’a” – what is yours belong to us all” and that "Everyone is equal". 

 Lavulo said the Fofo’anga strictly stick to the konitone.

“We believe every member should be treated equally from the lowest to the highest. We have a wide range of membership from unemployed to directors, ministers, lawyers, doctor of philosophers, and politicians to community leaders. When we mix and mingle everyone is treated equally without exception,” Lavulo said.

“We do not sell the kava, it is served free to everyone, even visitors, and that is just because of the konitone. There is no hierarchical organisation in the Fofo'anga meaning no executive body is selected to run the club. It just the secretary. I believe that is why the Fofo’anga is still operating since its first establishment in 1978,” he added.

“Members are only asked to donate fund when we have events like the celebration we had for the birthday. Other than that members are not bound by any financial obligations,” Lavulo said.

He said they used to celebrate the club’s birthday previously and this year members wanted to mark it along with Koloamatangi’s appointment to the Associate Professorship.

It could be seen that this was in contravention of our konitone as Koloamatangi appeared to have received special treatment. We have looked at it and everyone came to the conclusion that we have a responsibility to mark his associate professorship as it is important to support achievement in academia, Lavulo said.

Koloamatangi is one of the king of Tonga’s attendants and spokespersons and he was given the matāpule name Mafua-‘A e-Lulutai.

The name was first bestowed upon Koloamatangi’s father in 1978 by His Late Majesty Taufa’ahau Tupou IV.

King Tupou IV then bestowed the name upon Dr Koloamatangi  in 2006.

Mission

The Fofo’anga club has several aims including the fostering of music and donating funds to important causes.

Music is at the core of the club’s policies and players are taught to learn their chords and know how to sing the lead and harmonise. 

“We always say our band has to perform 110% all the time and members are encouraged to always do things to the best,” he said.

The club donates on quarterly basis to mission charities such as Auckland and Methodist Mission.

“In this project members are asked to donate whatever they would like to offer. We give them to the mission organisations in Auckland to help the poor.

“We have just also sent school materials to help Ha’apai Cyclone Victims and we will also award Fofo’anga scholarship this month at Massey University,” Lavulo said.

“We emphasize education this year and undertake to help ease the problem faced by our Tongan students in paying back of their student loans".

New Zealand chapters

Fofo’anga New Zealand was first established on 18 February, 1978.

In 1983 to 1985 it operated at Mohetaulanga Kupu’s residence at Universal Drive, Henderson. It was then returned to the 42 Dryden Street in Grey Lyn after the club building was built in 1987.

•        1991, club Late Mafua ‘a e Lulutai  were in Rotorua to establish the club with members Manu Taliauli, Haunga Taumoepeau and Mofini Vehekite.

•        2002, Maka Talau Brown and Mameisinimani Fataimelo(Seti Seth) established the club at number 10 Water Street, Otahuhu. It opens every Saturday.

•        2008, Rev. Pitasoni Fonua, Tatesi Toamotu, Siale, Latu Fe’ao and  Fanau To’utupu ‘Ohonua 'a e  Fofo’anga Taufa’ahau, established (zone 6)  Glen Innes Fofo'anga. It opens every Thursday.          

•        2010  Rev. Sifa Pole, Paula Halaleva established Fofo’anga Dunedin.

•        2011 Rev Luiaki Fakapelea and Suvenia Malupo established the club at Ashburton. It opens every Friday.

•        2012  Sione Alaiva’a Talia’uli, Sipia Tangi, Suka Naeata Rev. Nomani ‘Aho, ‘Akilisi Langi and Tu’a  established the Fofo’anga Counties – Manukau. It opens every Saturday.

•        2013 the club was established in Palmerston North, Manawatu by  Pilise Taufa and Lino

The Grey Lynn Fofo'anga chapter is at Mafua ‘a e Lulutai’s residence, 42 Dryden Street, Grey Lynn. It opens every Wednesday.

Incorporated

•        1989 – Fofo’anga was as an Incorporated Society.

•        1989 – 1994 –  Host Fafangu e Tapu, a weekly Radio Programme – ‘Access Community Radio 810am   (Planet FM 104.6).

•        1993-1994 – Record music albums. Fofo’anga band was featured in the ‘Tagata Pasifika’, TV1, TVNZ

•        1996 – ‘Open Door’ a programme hosted by Fofo’anga on TV3.

•        2008 – Fofo’anga Saute recorded hymn and Tongan Kakala songs together with Tonga’s well-known classical solo singer and composer,Tu’imala Kaho.

•        2012 – ‘Fofo’anga Youth and Family Trust’ established.

Tonga’s First Lady Robyn Kaho drunk, offensive and swears

Faka’apa’apa alert (Warning): Graphic language

Auckland, NZ – The Prime Minster of Tonga’s attempts to reform his image after he was found in the middle of a passport scandal appeared to have been shattered after his wife was drunk and made offensive remarks in an award dinner in Auckland last week.

The dinner was organised by the Auckland Langa’iva’inga Golf Club to mark its 2014 golf competition Saturday 29.

Organizers of the dinner were asked to call the police after several attempts to calm down Lady Robyn Tu'ivakano Kaho were unsuccessful.

She climbed tables and spilled a glass of wine onto the floor while diners were trying to talk her down.

The Fisrt Lady hid behind another woman after an editor of a Tongan newspaper turned his camera toward her.

The Prime Minister Lord Tu'ivakano was at the centre of a probe into Tongan passport irregularities reported in the news last week.

Kaho swore at Dr Fotu Fisi’iahi, the master of ceremony and called on the President of the Tonga Tau’ataina Church Semisi Fonua who was one of the quests she wanted more wine.  

Kaho, a member of the golf club, was believed to have entered the dinner drunk before she rambled and swore in Tongan while the MC was announcing the awards.

Fisi’iahi told Kaniva News he was trying to calm Kaho down but she swore at him.

“Who the loho are you? Fisi'iahi quoted Kaho as saying.

"I tried to take a glass of wine away from her but she spilled it onto the floor," Fisi'iahi said.

"We considered calling the police at the time in fear the restaurant might lose its license because of Kaho".

The Editor of the Kakalu 'o Tonga Newspaper, 'Ulu'alo Po'uhila  was at the dinner. He told Kaniva Kaho was really drunk and had no manners.

"I confronted her and she reacted and asked who I am? I responded that she would not know me but I am a Tongan and everyone was so embarrassed of what she was doing," Po'uhila said.

Kaho did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the story. Kaniva also contacted the Prime Minister for comments but nothing received at the time of writing..

Lady Joyce Robyn Tu'ivakano Kaho is being held down during the dinner. Photo / Kakalu 'o Tonga Newspaper

Comments

Reaction to the news by the Tongan community had been mixed. Many slammed  the First Lady for her inappropriate behaviour and putting the Prime Minister down and the Tongan public.

But a few asked why it was news and that the Tongan media should ignore her and publish something newsworthy.

It’s news as she is a public figure and her role as the Prime Minister’s wife requires her sense of decency and discipline to be maintained at all time especially in public places, a Tongan Facebook user said.  

Parliamentary session officially close tomorrow

THREE nobles of the realm will officially close the Legislative Assembly session for 2013/2014 on behalf of his Majesty during a soft closing ceremony tomorrow.

They are Hon. Luani, Kalaniuvalu Fotofili & Tu’iha’angana

This was announced by the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly, Lord Fakafanua when the House opens today.

One of the nobles will deliver a closing speech from his Majesty King Tupou VI from the throne.

The soft closing ceremony will start at 10am tomorrow.

Meanwhile the House will resume sitting in June to discuss the national budget for the new financial year 2014/2015.

Tu'ivakano could be impeached for disobeying king’s order: MP Isileli Pulu

The Prime Minister Lord Tu’ivakano could be impeached for defying the King’s order, said MP 'Isileli Pulu.

The king has ordered the Prime Minister in 2012 not to issue any more diplomatic passports to Chinese man Sien Lee.

Tonga’s Minister of Justice, Hon Clive Edwards told Television Tonga last week there was an order from the king regarding the diplomatic passports.

Edwards said under the Tongan law the king has the power to issue Tongan diplomatic passports.

Apart from the royals and Members of Parliament as well as Cabinet, Edwards said Tongan diplomatic passports  can only be issued to tourist commissioners or people who are representatives of Tonga.

Tongan diplomatic passports were given to Lee because he is a millionaire and he travels regularly, Edwards said.

Leaked emails revealed Tu’ivakano ignored the royal order and ordered the Foreign Affair’s secretary at the time, Mahe Tupouniua to issue Lee with a diplomatic passport in October 2012.

Tupouniua was told the Queen Mother wanted the passport for Lee because he was her very close friend.

Pulu, who was Tourism Minister in 2012, told Kaniva News, the Prime Minister is bound by the constitution to obey the king.

“When the Prime Minister and we MPs as well as ministers were sworn into office we swore before God that we will be truly loyal to His Majesty the rightful King of Tonga,” Pulu said.

“The constitution of Tonga is above everyone in the country and the Prime Minister should have obeyed the king’s order and not the Queen Mother”, he added.

Pulu said he is concerned the royals still have great influence in the government and the decision makers.

“Our undemocratic government still allow this to happen and this is our main problem,” Pulu said.

The Tongan diplomatic passports are being openly issued to Chinese millionaires and foreigners and Pulu said it is worrying because Tongan taxpayers are left in the dark without knowing who benefit from it.

He said the rule of law in Tonga is of great concern and the recent court case where two staff at the Immigration Department were jailed has proved the law is not working at the top level.

 “See, two Tongans have been sent to jail  because of illegal activities that connected them to abuse of just two Tongan passports. The sentence was made because the judge believed the abuse had been intentional.

“In my view, the Prime Minister knew really well that he swore to obey the king. And his order to issue the passport to Lee in contravention of the king’s order is a deliberate breach of his oath,” Pulu said.

The king might have known something about Lee and that was why he made the order, Pulu added.

Responding to the allegation the Prime Minister was involved in the passport scandal Edwards said he was aware of the king’s order.

“I know of the order as it was passed on to me but it was meant to cancel the diplomatic passports,” Edwards said in Tongan adding that that was really a difficult job to do as they have to cancel all diplomatic passports issued since the beginning.

Kaniva News understands the king's order was made directly for Mr Lee.

The Prime Minister told Tupouniua to issue Lee the passport as it was a request from the Queen Mother.

 “The reasoning I was given is that he is a friend of HM The Queen Mother and we Respect Her Wishes,” the email by Tupouniua said.

Tupouniua was worried if His Majesty knew they did not follow his advice.

“I will have to explain and bear the bunt at the next audience with Their Majesties,” the email said.

Auditor general: Passport scandals involved PM’s office

Tonga’s Auditor General Dr  Pohiva Tu’i’onetoa  said yesterday the passport scandal was one of  the two biggest he had come across in the past three years.

The Auditor General made his comments after Tonga’s Minister of Justice, Clive Edwards, told Radio and Television Tonga he suspected  the Auditor General of leaking information about the passport scandal to Kaniva News and the New Zealand media.

Edwards told the state broadcaster that  22 passports had been issued to a Chinese millionaire Sien Lee.

Dr Tu’i’onetoa compared the revelation of passport irregularities with the disappearance of millions of dollars of aid money from Australia and New Zealand.

The money was given to Tonga in 2010 to fund the kingdom’s political reforms.

He said millions of dollar disappeared without evidence  to show whether it was legally spent or on what.

The money was under the care of the former Prime Minister’s office at the time.

The Prime Minister’s Office appeared to have been involved in both scandals, he said.

No prosecution

When the Auditor’s office urged the Attorney General to charge the people involved, his office said they could not do anything because there was no law that could be used to launch a prosecution.

Dr Tu’i’onetoa said a dozen ordinary and diplomatic passports had been issued to 12 foreigners. They were not Tongans, had not been born in Tonga and did not hold any naturalisation certificates like Chinese-Tongans.

He told Kaniva News that when his office recommended the Attorney General to prosecute those involved, they were told the accused could not be prosecuted because the law that covered such  crimes was no longer valid.

Dr Tu’i’onetoa asked whether the lack of prosecution in these cases meant that people were free to do whatever they wanted.

“Does this mean the faults in the law will remain unfixed?”  he asked.

The Auditor General said he was concerned that the Prime Minister’s office appeared to have been involved in both cases.

He said it was important to maintain good governance in Tonga to facilitate economic and social development.

Legal

Justice Minister Clive Edwards said allegations that about 20 passport had been given to Sien Lee were true.

“That is true and I think there were more than that,” he told Television Tonga.

Edwards said the passports had been issued legally as Lee had been naturalized in 1993.

Dr Tu’i’onetoa said his office was permitted to release information about its investigations.

“The thing is I did not give you (Kaniva News) the leaked information,” he said

“The minister should cool down. He was quick to get furious.”

The Attorney General said his “principles are not for sale”.

He said someone had to do something to save Tonga from the situation it was in.

The main points

  • The Auditor General,  Dr Pohiva Tu’i’onetoa, has described the Tongan passport scandal as one of  the biggest he had come across in the past three years.
  • He said the Prime Minister’s office appeared to be involved in this and an earlier case in which millions of dollar of aid money from Australia and New Zealand had disappeared.
  • The Attorney General’s office had declined to prosecute anybody in either case.
  • Dr Tu’i’onetoa asked whether the lack of prosecution in these cases meant that people were free to do whatever they wanted in Tonga.

Tonga flooding: Call to declare state of emergency

Tongan Opposition Leader ‘Akilisi Pohiva has called on the government to declare a state of emergency after heavy rain and flooding across Tongatapu last week.

The House was told flooding had never been so widespread before.

Pohiva said his constituents were concerned by the frequency of the flooding and the lack of action by the government. 

“A woman came to me this morning, weeping while complaining about the flooding,” Pohiva said.

He attributed the level of flooding in his area to recent road construction by Chinese constructors.

The Opposition Leader said after work on the Sunia ‘Akaveka Road up to Hala ‘o Vave Road, properties within the area appeared to have been fenced in, allowing floodwater to collect.

Up to 80 percent of toilets in the area had been flooded.

Responding to Pohiva, Deputy Prime Minister Samiu Vaipulu, who is also Minister for Infrastructure, said three pumps had been working since the week before last week in Tongata’eapa.  

“We are just trying to keep down the level of the flooding as we cannot fight against Mother Nature,” he said. 

The Deputy Prime Minister said he had visited areas like Ha’atafu and Sopu and had never experienced such a volume of rain before.

He said flooding in the region was “really serious.”

Hihifo (Western) was hardest hit by the downpours, with localised flooding in some areas in the central area, the House was told.

Hundreds of homes were affected and pictures taken during the flooding suggest the flood waters may be up to 1 metre deep in places.

Vaipulu told the House he would call an emergency meeting with the Tongan National Emergency Committee.

Pohiva asked why he was going to call a meeting to gather information about the flooding when he knew how big the disaster was.

Vaipulu appealed to the Speaker about Pohiva’s interjection, but the Speaker told him the government already had enough information about the flooding and should act now.

The main points

  • Tongan Opposition Leader ‘Akilisi Pohiva has called on the government to declare a state of emergency after heavy rain and flooding across Tongatapu.
  • Both Dr Pohiva and Deputy Prime Minister Samiu Vaipulu said the amount of rain and extent of flooding were unprecedented.
  • In some places the flood level may be up to 1.5 metres deep
  • The Speaker of the Tongan Parliament supported Dr Pohiva and said the government should act immediately.

Edwards warns Tongan police and auditor’s office over passport leak

Tonga’s Minister for Justice Clive Edwards has warned Tonga’s Ministry of Police and the Auditor General, Dr Pohiva Tu’i’onetoa, over the leak of information about the Tongan passport scandal to Kaniva News and the New Zealand media.

In an interview with Radio and Television Tonga, the Justice Minister even implied that Australia and New Zealand might be involved in the leaks, claiming that they wanted to get access to Tongan Foreign Ministry records.

Edwards said New Zealand had condemned Tonga’s sale of passports.

Kaniva News reported that leaked e-mails showed that civil servants were worried that they had been ordered to provide passports to Chinese millionaire Sien Lee in direct contravention of an order from the king.

A report by the Auditor General’s office asked why 12 passports had been issued without the applicants holding naturalisation certificate. The response to the auditor from the Ministry of Foreign Affairs staff was that it was because of an order from “higher authority” to process them.

That “higher authority” has been identified as the Prime Minister, Lord Tu’ivakano .

However, the Justice Minister said the Auditor General’s report regarding the issuing of passports did not mean there were criminal activities involved.

Edwards said Lee was issued with diplomatic passports in 1993 before he became a minister in 1996 and as Police Minister he was given order to issue Lee with more diplomatic passports.

Lee, a very close friend of the late King Tupou IV, may have been issued with up to 12 passports.

Defence

Edwards said he met with the Prime Minister yesterday morning and said Lord Tu’ivakano did not really comprehend the allegations.

Edwards stopped short of denying the auditor’s report.

“When auditing is taking place they can ask questions like why did that happen?” the Justice Minister said.

“They took note of it so that they could check, but that does not mean there was something wrong as the auditing is still processing.”

In his report, the Auditor General said: “This practice is unacceptable and puts the country’s reputation at risk and should be discontinued immediately.”

Information leaks

“Only two sources could leak the information – the Ministry of Police or the Auditor General, Dr Pohiva Tu’i’onetoa,” Edwards said in Tongan.

He said leaking the documents was illegal.

“It is horrifying,” Edwards said.

He said it would have been inappropriate for Dr Tu’i’onetoa to release any documents

The Justice Minister described Dr Tu’i’onetoa’s interview with TVNZ last week as “a diversion” designed to disguise the source of the information.

Database

Edwards said he also suspected information could have been leaked to  Kaniva News from within the police.

Edwards said the Police Minister asked him to move the Foreign Affairs database to the care of the Ministry of Police.

“They promised they would not release any record, but not even a month passed before this information was leaked,” Edwards said.

 “I am absolutely dissatisfied that my record, the ministers’ records as well as people’s records have been taken to Police.”  

He said Australia and New Zealand had been trying to get access to the Foreign Affairs database for years.

E-mails

The Justice Minister said they contacted Mahe Tupoiniua on Thursday regarding the information that appeared in the Kaniva News.

He said Tupouniua said it was his internal memo to the staff and he was not sure whether what appeared on Kaniva was his.

It is normal for the Tongan government to take legal action against media if it carries defamatory or libellous information.

Edwards did not mention any legal action being taken against media for reporting the e-mails between the Ministry of Foreign Affairs staff or the auditor’s confidential report.

The main points

  • Tongan Minister for Justice Clive Edwards has named Tonga’s Ministry of Police and the Auditor General, Dr Pohiva Tu’i’onetoa, as possible sources of information about the Tongan passport scandal that were leaked to Kaniva News and the New Zealand media.
  • The Justice Minister even implied that Australia and New Zealand might be involved in the leaks, claiming that wanted to get access to Tongan Foreign Ministry records.
  • New Zealand has previously condemned Tonga’s sale of passports.
  • Edwards was responding to a report in Kaniva News and on TVNZ last week that the Tongan Ministry of Foreign Affairs was ordered by Prime Minister, Lord Tu’ivakano, to disobey a direct order from the king not to issue passports to a Chinese millionaire, Sien Lee.
  • It is believed  Lee may been issued with 12 passports, including four diplomatic documents.

[widgets_on_pages id = “Wid One”]